Best Homeowners Insurance For Older Homes   

Best Homeowners Insurance For Older Homes – This 2024, many home buyers are drawn to older houses for their classic charm and affordable prices. However, these homes often come with outdated plumbing and may need upgrades. Insurance companies see them as riskier and may charge more to insure them.

Best Homeowners Insurance For Older Homes   

As homeowners with older properties look for insurance, they face specific challenges. The reason is that these homes have unique features and may need updates to meet safety standards. Moreover, insurance rates depend on factors like the home’s age, condition, and historical value.

Finding the right insurance for older homes is crucial but can also be stressful. This is because it involves getting tailored coverage to address issues like replacing materials and updating old systems. But fret not, as we are here to help.

This blog post contains the best homeowners insurance companies you could use for your older homes in 2024. So, stick with us to find out and protect your home’s legacy while having peace of mind.

Best Homeowners Insurance for Older Homes In 2024

If you’re looking for suggestions on the top homeowners insurance for older homes in 2024, we’ve got you covered. Many insurance companies are known for their excellent customer service, flexibility, and coverage options. Here are a few popular insurance providers that stand out:

  • Amica Mutual.
  • Chubb.
  • The Hartford.
  • State Farm.
  • Nationwide.
  • American Family.
  • Farmers.
  • Travelers.
  • Erie Insurance.
  • Liberty Mutual.

Amica Mutual

Amica Mutual stands out as a top choice for homeowners insurance for older homes in 2024. Renowned for its exceptional customer service and high satisfaction ratings, Amica Mutual provides comprehensive coverage options tailored to the specific needs of older properties. This includes features like prolonged replacement cost coverage, ensuring peace of mind for homeowners.


Another standout insurance provider on the list is Chubb. They specialize in offering insurance coverage for high-value homes and provide quotes with features tailored to benefit older homes. For example, they offer risk consulting services, extended replacement cost coverage, and cash settlement options, ensuring comprehensive protection for older properties.

The Hartford

Partnering with AARP, The Hartford offers quotes suitable for older homeowners, focusing on protections such as “new for old” replacement and specialized services for repairing or rebuilding older structures. In addition to insurance for older homes, they also provide coverage for cars and a diverse range of business insurance options.

State Farm

State Farm is renowned for its local agents and high customer ratings, making it a top choice among insurance companies. With a broad network and a reputation for stability, State Farm offers customized service and coverage options that can be tailored to the specific needs of older homes. This includes features like law coverage and ordinance coverage, ensuring comprehensive protection for homeowners.


One of the top home insurance companies for older homes in 2024 is Nationwide. They provide ordinance or law insurance along with a coverage option called “Brand New Belongings,” which can be particularly beneficial for insuring older homes. This coverage ensures new replacements for old items and compliance coverage, offering comprehensive protection for homeowners.

American Family

For online resources, we suggest considering American Family. While their services are limited to 19 states and they may not offer as much policy customization as some competitors, American Family provides a variety of discounts that could be advantageous for budget-conscious older homeowners who are shopping around.


Another best homeowner insurance for older homes in 2024 is Farmers. This insurance company offers customizable coverage to interested clients and provides valuable discounts as well. In addition to this, farmers also provided guaranteed replacement coverage and extended replacement costs. However, the discount, coverage, availability, and accessibility might differ based on your location.


Deductible savings is a standout feature that places Travelers among the top homeowners insurance options for older homes in 2024. Additionally, Travelers Insurance provides a range of coverage options that can be particularly beneficial for older homes. Notably, it offers special coverage tailored for the restoration and preservation of historic features, making it an ideal choice for owners of historic or older properties.

Erie Insurance

Erie is popular for its competitive pricing and top-notch customer service. Additionally, they offer guaranteed replacement cost coverage in numerous states, a crucial feature for older homes where the cost of replacement may significantly surpass market values.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual boasts strong financial backing and a diverse array of endorsements. They excel at customizing quotes for the unique needs of older homes, offering inflation protection endorsements and coverage for water backup and sump overflow.

Tips To Getting The Best Policy For Your Old Home

Securing the best homeowners insurance for older homes in 2024 requires a meticulous approach that takes into account the unique vulnerabilities and distinctive characteristics of the property. To help you find the ideal policy for your older home, follow these steps:

  • Understand the specific needs of older homes.
  • Assess your home’s condition thoroughly.
  • Compile a list of home features requiring coverage.
  • Compare quotes from multiple insurers.
  • Look for insurers specializing in older homes.
  • Consider policies that offer replacement cost coverage.
  • Ensure sufficient liability coverage.
  • Inquire about available discounts and endorsements.
  • Review policy exclusions carefully.
  • Seek guidance from an independent agent.

By following these steps, you can find the perfect insurance protection for your older home, safeguarding both your property and personal belongings against potential risks.

Previous articleDo You Need Insurance To Ship A Car?
Next articleDo You Need Life Insurance in Retirement?